Central banks should lead by example on transparency and climate change

Freddie Collins 309833 Unsplash
Photo by Freddie Collins on Unsplash

Over 50 NGOs, including the Green Economy Coalition, have called on central banks to walk the talk when it comes to transparency and tackling climate change.


In a letter drawn up by the New Economics Foundation, more than 50 NGOs have called on central banks to lead by example when it comes to financial transparency over the risks and implications of climate change.  

The letter notes that G20 central banks and finance ministries have made commendable steps by putting climate change firmly on the financial stability agenda. As Governor of the Bank of England Mark Carney has suggested, the severity of climate risks could result in a “climate Minsky moment”, involving system-wide collapse in prices as companies in the fossil fuel industry rapidly lose their value.

A successful green transition means re-aligning finance and capital to a more ecologically sustainable footing. However, it also means deflating potentially the biggest asset price bubble in history: the ‘carbon bubble’.

“Climate change and deflating the ‘carbon bubble’ has the potential to wipe out trillions of pounds worth of assets, making the devastation of the 2008 financial crisis seem like a walk in the park.”

Forecasts suggest that only one quarter of remaining fossil fuel reserves can be burned if we are to keep to the Paris Climate Agreement and stop temperatures rising above 2°C. Leaving most of the world’s oil, gas and coal in the ground means carbon intensive assets may be grossly overpriced, and infrastructure built to extract the reserves may become useless (known as ‘stranded assets’).

Climate change and deflating the ‘carbon bubble’ has the potential to wipe out trillions of pounds worth of assets, making the devastation of the 2008 financial crisis seem like a walk in the park.

In response to the risks, G20 central banks and finance ministries have established the Task Force on Climate-related Financial Disclosures (TCFD). Taking the first meaningful stride towards addressing the financial risks of climate change, the TCFD has developed a voluntary, consistent reporting framework for climate-related financial disclosures.

According to Governor Carney, climate risks and opportunities are currently “shrouded in secrecy”, and the more transparent we make markets “the more we will all benefit”. In theory, greater transparency will allow the market to price in risks of climate change, enabling better long-term decisions.

However, whilst there are some notable success stories, best practice has not yet been establish, neither for companies or for banks. Indeed, following reports that the UKs largest pension funds fail to sufficiently consider climate change, a group of MPs have called on government to make climate-related risk disclosures mandatory by 2022.

Bankof England Flickr
Mark Carney, Governor of the Bank of England. Image: Bank of England / Flickr

Until then, private financial sector institutions need an authoritative example for how to report TCFD disclosure recommendations, and to help tackle potential collective action problems of leaving it to the market. Central banks are well-placed strategically to spearhead this movement.

As the 50 NGOs writing to the FT have argued, central banks should lead by example given that they have themselves built-up portfolios of corporate securities that are highly skewed towards carbon intensive sector. As the Bank of England is a public sector institution, this means government’s balance sheet is also significantly exposed to potential climate related risks.  

It also begs a simple question: Can we really expect private institutions to voluntarily, publicly disclose their business strategies and risk exposures to climate change while leading public institutions are unwilling to do so?

Improving central bank transparency may be an essential first step, but it must also be the thin end of a larger policy wedge. For example, the Bank of England’s own corporate quantitative easing (QE) programme acts as a subsidy for carbon intensive sectors and risks reinforcing the current ‘carbon lock-in’ of energy systems centred upon fossil fuels, which endangers financial stability and undermines the Paris Agreement on climate change.

With this letter we are asking on central banks to be responsible and lead by example – by increasing their transparency and disclosing their climate-related risks, the long-term hope must be that central banks will ultimately redesign their QE programmes in order to help clean up their balance sheet. And ultimately maybe this will mean that central banks start to think more strategically about how they can support the green transition and Paris Climate commitments.

With over 50 key NGOs now united and calling for central banks to act, can Mark Carney ensure the UK continues to lead the way on tackling climate change?

Full List of Signatories of the Letter

ATTAC Norge, 
ATTAC Ireland,
Banktrack,
Better Europe Public Affairs,
Christian Aid,
Conseil Scientifique de la Fondation pour la Nature et L'Homme,
Climate Strategy and Partners, 
Cogito,
Corporate Europe Observatory,
Debt Resistance UK,
Next Systems Project - Democracy Collaborative,
E3G,
Ecopreneur,
European Environment Bureau,
European Alternatives,
European initiative for a Finance-Climate Pact, 
Finance Innovation Lab,
Finance Watch,
Friends of the Earth England, Wales and Northern Ireland,
Friends of the Earth Europe,
German Watch,
Global Justice Now,
Global Forest Coalition,
Global Sustainability Institute,
Anglia Ruskin University,
Global Witness,
Global Warning,
Green Budget Europe,
Green Economy Coalition,
Greenpeace International,
Institute for Law and the Environment,
Institute Veblen,
International Trade Union Confederation,
Jubilee Debt Foundation,
Leave it in the Ground Initiative (LINGO),
New Economics Foundation,
NOAH - Friends of the Earth Denmark,
Notre affaire à tous Oikos,
Positive Money (UK),
Positive Money (EZ),
Profundo,
Purposeful Money,
Rethinking Economics,
Royal Society for the Encouragement of Arts, Manufactures and Commerce,
Share Action,
Social Value UK,
SolarAid,
SOMO,
Stamp Out Poverty,
Transparency International,
Transparency Task Force,
World Future Council